Alexandria
Library -- Special Collections
Document of the Month
September 2007
Primary Source Documents
According to the Library of Congress: “Primary sources are
actual records that have survived from the past, like letters, photographs,
articles of clothing and music. They are different from secondary sources, which
are accounts of events written sometime after they happened.” A primary
source is a first-hand account of something or someone, whereas a secondary
source is an interpretation or analysis of that account. When looking to understand
primary sources, it is important to identify the purpose and the source of the
document. For example, your diary is a primary source document. A book about
your life using your diary is a secondary source. It is not always easy to recognize
primary sources from secondary. The documents below provide a good example of
some of the questions that arise when identifying them.
Can
you identify which of these documents is a primary source document?
On January 27, 1870, a group of Alexandria merchants and citizens
signed a letter to the General Assembly of Virginia recommending Edward Sangster,
a lawyer, to the position of Judge of the County Court. The handwritten letter
and a type-set version are part of the Sangster Papers at the Special Collections
branch. In addition to their depiction of Alexandria events, these papers demonstrate
an important lesson in the identification of primary source documents. Look
carefully at the two images below and see if you can you identify the primary
source.
Hint: In this case, the answer is not
in the format. You can also place your mouse over the images for additional
clues and questions to consider.
And the answer is...
Although the papers look different, they are both the first account
of an event, the actual records of the past, and are the surviving documents
from this moment in time. So, the answer is...both.
Examining Primary Sources
Primary source documents present the opportunity
to learn about people and events through first-hand accounts. They give you
the chance to critically examine materials of the past and develop your own
conclusions about them. The two papers shown above are particularly interesting
after examining the differences and the similarities between them. Like many
primary sources, these papers raises as many questions as they answer.
What are some differences between
these two documents?
At first glance it appears that the text is the same and the
format is the only difference between these items. However, upon closer inspection
it is evident that the text is slightly different and that not all of the names
are the same. There are only four names that appear on both documents. Those
names are: F.L. Brockett of Brawner & Co.; Geo. H. Robinson of George H.
& Sons, commercial merchant; S.King Shay, teacher; and C.F. Suttle of Suttle
& Stuart, commercial merchant and plastermill owner. Why are these the only
names on both items? Are there additional pages to the handwritten document
that show more names? Please contact the Special Collections branch if you have
information about any of these items, individuals, or this event. Send us an
email.
More about the names on the handwritten document (according
to the Alexandria City Directories, 1870 & 1871):
- Geo. H. Robinson - George H. Robinson of George H. & Sons, Commercial
Merchant, located at 27 King Street
- Enoch Fring - Not listed
- C.F. Suttle - Charles F. Suttle of Suttle & Stuart, Commercial Merchant
and Plastermill Owner, located at 112 Cameron Street
- D. Howard - David Howard, Commercial Merchant, located at 52 King Street
- John W. Arnold - John W. Arnold, Hats & Caps, located at 81 King Street
- F.L. Brockett - F.L. Brockett of Brawner & Co., located at 80 N. Washington
Street
- Wm. H. Smith - Wm. H. Smith, Huckster, located at 104. N. Alfred Street
- C.H. House - Charles H. House, Printer, located at 97 N. Columbus Street
- R.W. Robinson - Richard W. Robinson, Tailor, located at 8 S. Fairfax Street
- Charles Javins - Charles Javins of L. Cook & Co., located at 38 N. Fairfax
Street
- Wm A. Johnson - W. A. Johnson of W.A. Johnson & Co., Produce Dealer,
located at 24 N. Fairfax Street
- William Javins - William Javins, either Bricklayer located at 39 S. Water
or Baker located at 137 S. Water Street
- Wm. W. Rock - William Rock, Blacksmith, located at 98 S. Water Street
- C. Schafer - Christian Schafer, Confectioner, located at 3 N. Fairfax Street
- G. Krieg - G. Krieg, Undertaker, located at 14 N. Fairfax Street
- H.K. Bradshaw - H.K. Bradshaw, Commercial Rev., located at 12 S. St. Asaph
Street
- S. H. Coleman - Samuel S. Coleman, Moulder, located at 99 S. Fairfax Street
- John H. Thompson - John H. Thomas, Oyster Dealer, located on Water Street
at the corner of Duke Street
- Wm. S. Hough - William S. Hough, Printer, located on Wilkes Street at the
corner of Pitt Street
- Luther H. Thompson - Not listed
- C.A.S. Cough - Not listed
- J. Fisher - Either Jonas Fisher of AO&MRR, Assistant Superintendent,
located at 173 Duke Street or Jesse Fisher, Driver located at 113 Prince Street
- W. Stewart - Wm. Stewart, Laborer, located on Fayette Street near Cameron
Street
- John H. Lloyd - John H. Lloyd, Bootfitter, located on Fairfax Street near
Gibbon Street
- Wm. H. Fitzhugh - Wm H Fitzhugh was located at 35 Prince Street in 1870
and 17 Water Street in 1871.
- S. King Shay - S. King Shay, Teacher, located on 87 S. Pitt Street
More on the names on the typed document (according
to the Alexandria City Directories, 1870 & 1871):
- C.F. Suttle - Charles F. Suttle of Suttle & Stuart, Commercial Merchant
and Plastermill Owner, located at 112 Cameron Street
- Geo. H. Robinson - George H. Robinson of George H. & Sons, Commercial
Merchant, located at 27 King Street
- W.H. Marbury - William H. Marbury of OA&MRR, Treasurer, located on
Prince Street between Pitt and Royal Streets
- W.W. Adam - Wallace W. Adam, Watches & Jewelry, located at 78 King
Street
- A. McLean - Anthony McLean of OA&MRR, Auditor, located at 168 King
Street
- Wm. H. Irwin - William H. Irwin, located at 182 Prince Street
- H. W. Vandergrift - Henry W. Vandergrift of OA&MRR, Superintendent,
located at 39 S. Washington Street
- Wm. B. Price - This is either Wm. B. Price of Prince & Willis, Commercial
Merchant, located at 7 S. Columbus Street or Assistant Freight Agent, located
at 273 King Street
- Thomas A. Watters - not listed
- George Duffey - George N. Duffey, Watchmaker, located at 125 King Street
- F.L. Brockett - F.L. Brockett of Brawner & Co., located at 80 N. Washington
Street
- J.M. Broadus - James M. Broadus of OA&MRR, General Ticket Agent, located
at 168 King Street
- S. King Shay - S. King Shay, Teacher, located at 87 S. Pitt Street
- Dan'l Morgan - Daniel Morgan of OA&MRR, Paymaster, located at 168 King
Street
- C. Powell - Charles Powell of OA&MRR, Superintendent Freight, located
on Patrick Street near King Street
- P.G. Uhler - Peter G. Uhler, Bookkeeper, located at 15 N. Washington Street
- C.G. Brown - Charles G. Brown, Commercial Merchant, located at 69 S. St.
Asaph Street
- L.L. Loving - L.L. Loving of Loving & Pierce, Commercial Merchant,
located at 62 S. Royal or 8 Union
- Thomas J. Mchaffey - not listed
- John F. Dyer - Perhaps John W. Dyer, Blacksmith, located at Union Street
between Queen and Cameron Street
Do you recognize a common theme
among the signers?
Many worked for the OA&MRR, the Orange, Alexandria & Manassas Railroad.
The Orange and Alexandria Railroad was established in the 1848. It was an important
gateway to Virginia's Piedmont during the Civil War. The Manassas Gap Railroad
was established in 1850. Although much of the right-of-way was cleared, the
railroad was incomplete by the start of the Civil War and rebuilding after the
war was difficult. Many railroad companies experienced financial troubles after
the Civil War forcing them to merge. The Orange and Alexandria and the Manassas
Gap Railroad Companies were no exception. By the 1870's, these companies merged
together to create the Orange, Alexandria & Manassas Railroad. Interestingly,
one of the stations on this railroad route carries the Sangster family
name: Sangster Station in Fairfax County.
Related Resources:
- Alexandria (Va.). Dept. of Planning and Urban Renewal. Rail Transit:
Relationship to Other Planning Considerations. Alexandria, Dept. of City
Planning and Urban Renewal, 1966. Va. Ref. 388.42 Ale
- Brechenser, Donn M. Railroads of Northern Virginia. Bernardston,
Mass.: Valley Offset Print. Co., c1971. Va. Ref. 625.1 Bre
- Cox, Al. An Analysis of the Alexandria Union Station, 1994/95.
Alexandria, Va.: City of Alexandria, Department of Transportation and Environmental
Services, 1995. Va. Ref. 725.31 Cox
- Orange and Alexandria Railroad Co. Microfilm 00580
- Pittenger, William. Daring and Suffering: A History of the Great Railroad
Adventure. Alexandria, Va.: Time-Life Books, 1982. Va. Ref. 973.732
Pit
- Slusser, H. Robert. Mr. Lincoln's Railroad Car: An Alexandria Artifact.
Alexandria, Va.: Alexandria Archaeology, Office of Historic Alexandria, 1996.
Va. Ref. 385.33 Slu
- Swank, Walbrook D. Train Running for the Confederacy, 1861-1865.
Mineral, Va: W.D. Swank, c1990. Va. Ref. 973.78 Swa
- Traser, Donald R. Virginia Railway Depots. Richmond, Va.: Old Dominion
Chapter, National Railway Historical Society, c1998. Va. Ref. 385.314
Tra
- Vertical File: Railroads - Orange and Alexandria
Document
of the Month Archives
Special
Collections Home || Guide to Special
Collections || Virtual
Tour || Online
Exhibits || Genealogy
Resources || Online Collection
Guides || Useful Links
|| News and Events
|| Bookshop
|| Contact Us Library Catalog
|| Alexandria
Library Home
Web Page by Michele Lee
© 2007 Alexandria Library
|